π¨π¦ CanadaCatalog recipe Β· Ontario
Flaky pastry shells filled with a bubbling caramel of butter, brown sugar and egg, baked until the edges crisp and the centers stay soft and runny.
For 12 servings.
No reviews yet
Cooked this? Be the first to tell everyone how it went.
Sign in to rate and review this recipe.
Sign in to suggest corrections and improvements.
Community posts are opinions, not professional advice. Community guidelines
Videos belong to their creators and play on their platformβs terms β Cibora never re-hosts third-party video.
Buy these ingredients
Links open each storeβs own site, where you see their live local prices. Our cost figures in the app are estimates only.
Rub the cold butter into the flour until crumbly, then bring together with ice water into a dough; chill 30 minutes.
Roll the dough thin and cut rounds slightly larger than the muffin cups; press into the tin.
Scatter a few raisins into each shell, if using.
Whisk melted butter, brown sugar, corn syrup, eggs and vanilla into a smooth, pourable filling.
Pour the filling into the shells until two-thirds full β they puff and can overflow if filled higher.
π‘ Leave real headroom; a too-full tart bakes over the edge and welds itself to the tin.
Bake at 200Β°C for 12β15 minutes until the filling bubbles and the pastry is golden.
π‘ Pull them just as the centers stop looking wet at the very middle β that's what keeps them runny once cooled.
Cool in the tin 10 minutes before lifting out; the filling is molten straight from the oven.
Butter tarts trace to early Ontario settler kitchens and appear in print as far back as a 1900 Barrie, Ontario community cookbook, built from pantry staples that survived Canadian winters: butter, sugar, eggs and corn syrup. Bakeries across Ontario and the Prairies still argue over the right filling texture β runny versus set, raisins versus plain. It remains one of the few pastries widely claimed as distinctly Canadian.
No suggestions yet. Spotted a wrong quantity, a missing step, or a better technique? Suggest it β accepted changes join the recipeβs version history.
Sign in to join the discussion. Reading is open to everyone.
Nothing here yet β questions about technique, timing, and substitutions all welcome.